Replacing a gas pool heater: heat pump, solar or both?

Quick answer: For most Adelaide homes, a heat pump is the natural replacement for a gas pool heater. It produces 4 to 6 units of heat for every unit of electricity it uses, where gas turns less than one unit of fuel into one unit of heat. Solar is cheaper again to run if your roof suits it. Gas still heats fastest, so it only really makes sense for pools heated occasionally and in a hurry.
Gas pool heaters had their day. They're compact, they heat fast, and for years they were the default. But more and more of our calls now start with an old gas heater that's died, or a gas bill that's got out of hand, and the same question: what should go in instead?
Here's how we'd think it through.

Why people are moving away from gas pool heating
Three reasons come up again and again.
Running cost. A gas heater burns fuel to make heat, so the best it can do is turn one unit of energy into slightly less than one unit of heat. A heat pump moves heat that's already in the air into your pool, which is why it delivers several units of heat per unit of power.
Holding temperature. Gas is great at a fast heat-up and expensive at holding a pool warm all season. Most families want the pool ready whenever they are, and that's exactly where gas costs the most.
Solar PV. A lot of Adelaide homes now have panels on the roof. A heat pump can run on your own daytime solar power. A gas heater can't.
Gas vs heat pump vs solar compared
Gas heater | Heat pump | Solar | Solar plus heat pump | |
Heat-up speed | Fastest, hours | 1 to 4 days for a full heat-up | Gradual, sun-dependent | Fast enough, steady |
Energy in vs heat out | Under 1 unit of heat per unit of gas | 4 to 6 units of heat per unit of power | Heat from the sun is free | Mostly free, heat pump tops up |
Holding temperature | Costly | Efficient, set and forget | Varies with weather | Steady all season |
Runs on your solar PV | No | Yes | Not needed | Yes |
Roof space needed | No | No | Yes, roughly your pool's surface area | Yes |
Best for | Occasional, fast heating | Most family pools, year-round swimming | Lowest running cost, 7 to 8 month season | Year-round with the lowest bills |
Want the full side-by-side on the two main options? See our solar vs heat pump comparison.
Check the running cost against your own bills
Energy prices move, so rather than quote numbers that will date, here's the formula. Grab your last gas and electricity bills.
Gas cost per kWh of heat = (gas price in cents per MJ x 3.6) ÷ heater efficiency
Heat pump cost per kWh of heat = electricity price in cents per kWh ÷ COP
An example with round numbers. If gas costs you 4 cents per MJ and your heater is 85 percent efficient, heat costs about 17 cents per kWh. If power costs you 40 cents per kWh and your heat pump averages a COP of 5, heat costs about 8 cents per kWh. Run the heat pump on your own solar PV through the day and it drops further.
Put your own numbers in. On most Adelaide bills we see, the heat pump wins clearly.
What's involved in swapping gas for a heat pump
It's usually a simpler job than people expect.
Site check. We look at where the old heater sits, airflow around the new unit, noise toward your neighbours and bedrooms, and your switchboard.
Sizing. Most family pools of 40,000 to 60,000 litres suit a 13 to 17 kW heat pump. Year-round swimming may need more. Our heat pump sizing calculator gives you a starting point.
Electrical. A heat pump needs a suitable dedicated circuit. Our licensed electrician handles this as part of the install.
Plumbing. The heat pump plumbs into your filtration line, often close to where the gas heater was.
The old gas heater. It's disconnected and the gas line made safe by a licensed gas fitter, then removed.
Our heat pump installation page walks through the process in more detail, and the Guardian Eco Pro range is where most gas replacements land. Prices for every model are in our pool heat pump range. If the new unit has to sit near a fence, bedroom window or garden bed, an air discharge deflector turns its cold outlet air away from them.
When solar makes more sense
If you've got a north, east or west-facing roof with little shade and roughly as much area as your pool's surface, solar pool heating has the lowest running cost of any option. The sun does the work, and you only run your existing pool pump. Confident on a roof? Our DIY solar pool heating kits ship with the same Zane collectors we install.
The trade-off is control. Solar gives you a long season, typically seven to eight months in Adelaide, but it can't heat on demand in a cloudy week. That's why a lot of gas replacements end up as solar plus a heat pump: solar carries most of the load, the heat pump tops up when you need it.
What to do next
Note your pool volume and the months you want to swim.
Pull your last two energy bills and run the formula above.
Check your roof for solar suitability.
Book a site visit. We'll quote heat pump, solar and both, so you can compare them properly.
Ready to retire the gas heater?
We've been heating Adelaide pools since 1979 and we'll give you a fixed-price quote for each option after a free onsite visit. Call (08) 8349 4333 or book online.
Frequently asked questions
Is a heat pump cheaper to run than a gas pool heater?
In most cases, yes. A heat pump delivers 4 to 6 units of heat per unit of electricity, while a gas heater delivers less than one unit of heat per unit of gas. Run your own tariffs through the formula above to confirm for your home.
Does a heat pump heat a pool as fast as gas?
No. Gas is faster for a cold start. But a heat pump is designed to hold a steady temperature all season, so after the first heat-up the pool is simply ready when you are.
Can I reuse my gas heater's plumbing and location?
Often, yes. Heat pumps plumb into the same filtration line. The new unit needs good airflow and a suitable electrical circuit, which we check on the site visit.
What size heat pump replaces a gas pool heater?
It's sized to your pool, not to the old heater. Most Adelaide family pools of 40,000 to 60,000 litres suit a 13 to 17 kW heat pump, with larger units for year-round swimming or exposed sites.
Can I keep my gas heater as a backup?
You can, although most people find they never use it once a correctly sized heat pump and a pool blanket are in place. We can talk through the options on site.






Comments